When is IBS Diagnosed? - A Closer Look at IBS

Do you know that IBS is a diagnosis of exclusion? And it affects 20-45 million Americans!

Before you start recalling your great-step-aunt’s GI issues in your head, defending the existence of IBS, take a pause and read on. (Exclusion doesn't mean that it doesn't exist!)


IBS stands for Irritable Bowel Syndrome and is a very real experience. It comes with a long list of uncomfortable and painful symptoms such as abdominal pain, bloating belly, distension, and diarrhea, not to mention many symptoms that are not usually directly associated with IBS. These symptoms include, fatigue, weight loss or gain, hormonal imbalances, anxiety, and general pain. 


IBS is a diagnosis of exclusion, that is, ruling out other etiologies. Etiologic factors (factors that cause diseases) that should be ruled out include: infection (bacterial – esp. C. difficile, viral fungal or parasitic), pancreatic insufficiency, celiac disease, food sensitivities, lactose intolerance, and SIBO, as well as a host of other conditions that can mimic IBS.


Simply put: IBS is generic for “we don't really know what's going on, but we see you have a lot of symptoms that aren’t normal.”


But this doesn’t mean they’ve told you why you have IBS. And probably more importantly how to heal.


Why do people get IBS?

“The pathogenesis of IBS is multifactorial, with contributions from visceral hypersensitivity (low threshold to painful stimuli arising from the GI tract), neuroendocrine dysfunction, psychosocial factors, stress, enteric infections, altered GI flora, foods sensitivities/allergies, and other factors. New research on treatment of IBS highlights diet and nutrition, psychoneuroendocrinology, commensal bacteria and the immune system.” In addition, disordered cortical pain processing, SIBO and increased intestinal permeability have also been recently implicated.


Stress and emotional distress affect gastrointestinal function and worsen the symptoms of IBS. “Individuals with IBS have higher levels of postprandial serotonin, which corresponds to altered gastric emptying, increased small bowel contractions, faster bowel transit time, and altered pain perception (visceral hypersensitivity). IBS can also develop after an enteric infection known as post-infectious IBS (PI-IBS).

Recent studies have also shown altered gut immune activation, and intestinal and colonic microbiome are associated with IBS.


The differential diagnosis of IBS is broad and ultimately depends on whether the patient has predominant diarrhea or constipation. If a patient has IBS with diarrhea, the differentials includes lactose intolerance, caffeine intake, alcohol intake, gastrointestinal infections (Giardia, Amoeba, HIV), inflammatory bowel disease, medication-induced diarrhea (antibiotic use, proton pump inhibitor, nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drugs, ACE inhibitor, chemotherapy), celiac disease, malignancies, colorectal cancer, hyperthyroidism, VIPoma, and ischemic colitis.


So what conditions can mimic IBS?

Take a look at the (not exhaustive) list:


  • Gastrogenic dietary factors such as excessive consumption of tea, coffee, carbonated beverages, and simple sugars
  • Infectious enteritis such as amebiasis and giardiasis
  • Inflammatory bowel disease
  • Lactose intolerance
  • Laxative abuse
  • Intestinal candidiasis
  • Disturbed bacterial microflora as a result of antibiotic or antacid use
  • Malabsorption disease such as pancreatic insufficiency and celiac disease
  • Metabolic disorders such as adrenal insufficiency, diabetes mellitus, and hyperthyroidism
  • Mechanical causes of fecal impact
  • Diverticular disease
  • Neoplasm


Has your doctor diagnosed you with IBS? Are you curious if you have IBS? Learn more about how I helped Katherine with her IBS or click to Work with Me so I can help you bring more balance to your body.




References:

Chey WD, Kurlander J, Eswaran S. Irritable bowel syndrome: a clinical review. JAMA. 2015 Mar 03;313(9):949-58.

Simrén M, Barbara G, Flint HJ, Spiegel BM, Spiller RC, Vanner S, Verdu EF, Whorwell PJ, Zoetendal EG., Rome Foundation Committee. Intestinal microbiota in functional bowel disorders: a Rome foundation report. Gut. 2013 Jan;62(1):159-76.

Dupont HL. Review article: evidence for the role of gut microbiota in irritable bowel syndrome and its potential influence on therapeutic targets. Aliment Pharmacol Ther. 2014 May;39(10):1033-42.

Lucak S. Diagnosing irritable bowel syndrome: what's too much, what's enough? MedGenMed. 2004 Mar 12;6(1):17.


Don't Miss Out On More!

Heidi Toy FNTP

I help people all over the world heal by identifying and treating the root cause of their body imbalances. Through diet and nutrition, I guide them towards wholeness and balanced lives.

Heidi Toy Functional Medicine Blog

By Heidi Toy May 11, 2026
Alpha-gal syndrome symptoms, red meat allergy, tick-borne allergy, delayed food allergy, alpha-gal test
By Heidi Toy May 6, 2026
How Silicone Breast Implants May Contribute to Autoimmune Responses and Health Issues
heavy metal toxins affect autoimmunity
By Heidi Toy April 29, 2026
What you should know about heavy metal detox if you have an autoimmune disease.
By Heidi Toy April 21, 2026
When it comes to autoimmune conditions, many of my clients are eager to find answers about the foods that could be triggering their symptoms. They often think, "If I just avoid certain foods, I’ll feel better." But, what they might not realize is that food combinations can play a huge role in causing autoimmune flare-ups, even when the individual ingredients don’t show antibodies on their own. It’s a tricky and often frustrating area of functional medicine, but understanding it is key to healing. Here's what you need to know. Understanding Food Protein Reactions Let’s start with the basics. In a perfect world, food sensitivities and allergies are pretty straightforward. You eat a food, your body reacts, and you know exactly what caused the problem. Unfortunately, with autoimmune disease, the story is more complex. As a functional medicine practitioner trained under Dr. Datis Kharrazian, I don’t just look at individual foods—I look at immune response. And food proteins can behave very differently when combined. You may have a test that shows no antibodies for specific foods, think chicken, potatoes, or broccoli. But when those foods are cooked together in a meal, something changes. The proteins in those foods could combine in a way that causes your immune system to recognize them as a threat, triggering an autoimmune flare-up. The reason for this is cross-reactivity, where similar amino acid sequences in different food proteins can cause your immune system to confuse one food for another. This phenomenon is real, and it's something I see often in my practice. Just because a food doesn’t show a reaction on its own doesn’t mean it won’t cause issues when combined with others. The Role of Cross-Reactivity Cross-reactivity happens when your immune system mistakes one protein for another because they share a similar amino acid sequence. For example, if you react to salmon, you might also react to other types of fish due to similarities in their protein structures. This concept is why combining foods like certain grains, dairy, and legumes might trigger reactions in some individuals, even if they’ve tested negative for antibodies to those foods. Let’s look at a real-world example. Imagine eating a gluten-free Kung Pao chicken that’s free of contamination. You’d think that meal would be perfectly fine, right? But if that combination of chicken, spices, and vegetables triggers a reaction, it could be because of how the proteins in those foods interact once combined. Why You Should Pay Attention to Food Combinations In the context of autoimmune disease, where your immune system is already overactive, food reactions can be subtle and unpredictable. So, the next time you’re tempted to dismiss a food intolerance because a test didn’t flag it, think again. It’s not just about the individual foods—it’s about how they interact in your body. You need to pay close attention to how different food combinations make you feel. It’s easy to get caught up in thinking that food sensitivities only apply to the big culprits: gluten, dairy, or soy. But as an autoimmune patient, it’s essential to understand that your body might be reacting to the interaction of multiple foods. So while a test might show that chicken and broccoli are “safe” on their own, eating them together in a casserole could trigger symptoms. The N=1 Approach to Autoimmunity and Food Sensitivities Here’s the bottom line: There is no one-size-fits-all approach when it comes to food and autoimmunity. As I always tell my clients, you are the expert on your own body. Testing can give us a great starting point, but it’s your unique experience that helps us narrow in on what’s truly causing your flare-ups. This is why food sensitivity testing—while helpful—is just one part of the puzzle. You have to be keenly aware of your body’s reactions and the foods you’re combining, even if the individual ingredients test negative for antibodies. Don’t ignore what your body is telling you. If something doesn’t feel right after a meal, listen to it, and make adjustments accordingly. The Takeaway If you're struggling with autoimmune symptoms and haven't been paying attention to food combinations, it’s time to start. While food testing is an invaluable tool, it doesn’t give us the full picture. You may need to do some trial and error with food combinations to uncover what’s really triggering your symptoms. It’s also important to remember that autoimmune healing is complex and individualized. You are an N=1, which means your treatment plan should be tailored to you. Don’t be afraid to advocate for your health, and work with a functional medicine practitioner who can help guide you through the nuances of food reactions and autoimmune management. Are you struggling to identify food sensitivities or autoimmune triggers? Let's work together to find a personalized solution that addresses your unique needs. You are welcome to start with a Free Health Discovery Session.
By Heidi Toy October 14, 2025
For many of us, our experience with food comes with some sort of baggage. Maybe you eat to cope with stress, anxiety or depression. Maybe you’ve grown up with value-words placed on food such as “junk” and “healthy,” and told you couldn’t eat the “good stuff” (brownies and ice cream) until you finished the “yucky stuff” (broccoli and lettuce). Or, even more serious, maybe you or a loved one has struggled or is struggling with an eating disorder. Food is amazing and life-giving. It can be used as a means to celebrate, socialize, or simply just provide fuel for the body. Our relationship with food shouldn’t be a difficult one, it should be an enjoyable one. A way to get to that healthy place in your relationship is to practice mindful eating. Mindfulness is a Buddhist concept of mediation that can help you recognize emotions and physical sensations present. Through mindful eating, you can learn to truly pay attention to your experiences, cravings and physical cues. The basics of mindful eating are: Eat slowly, without distraction. If you are eating with others, take a least five minutes at the start of the meal to enjoy the food on your plate before engaging in discussion. Pay attention to your body--are you still hungry, or are you getting full? Learn to distinguish between cravings and true hunger. Use all your senses when you sit down to a meal. Make an effort to notice how the food looks, smells, tastes, feels in your mouth, and sounds when you chew. Appreciate your food, who has prepared it (even if it’s you--what an accomplishment!), and where it comes from.  Being mindful of your experience will help you slow down while eating. This can prevent overindulgence by making the act of eating intentional instead of automatic. It will also help you become aware of triggers that make you want to eat (are you truly hungry at 9pm every night when you sit down to watch that Netflix show, or do you just pour yourself a bowl of Chex Mix because that’s what you always do?). Knowing your triggers can give you time to process what’s truly going on and the ability to react properly.
By Heidi Toy October 14, 2025
Are you struggling with fatigue, frequent infections, or other health issues? It could be a sign of glutathione deficiency. Learn more here.
By Heidi Toy October 2, 2025
Here are the essential functional medicine steps for Fifth Disease! If your child comes home with bright red cheeks that look like they’ve been “slapped,” chances are they may have fifth disease, also known as erythema infectiosum. This mild viral illness, caused by parvovirus B19, is common in kids and often spreads t
By Heidi Toy September 14, 2025
Successfully healing Adrenal Fatigue requires a holistic approach focussed on fixing the root cause of your problems and supporting your body through the healing process. This means we are going beyond just temporary symptom relief. We want you to return to vibrant health so you can get back to the active and healthy lifestyle that Adrenal Fatigue is holding you back from. (Adrenal Fatigue is more accurately known as HPA-D. Check out my blog HPA-D vs Adrenal Fatigue to learn more.)Again, we would be completing further testing to get to the root cause of your issues, but this protocol is a great starting point for healing. We focus on five essential areas for fast and long-term healing.
By Heidi Toy August 14, 2025
Change up where/how you purchase your food.
By Heidi Toy August 4, 2025
How Food Sensitivities Fuel Autoimmune Flares—And What to Do About It
More Posts